FDA COMPLIANCE · RECALLS
Quick answer
FDA sorts recalls into three classes by health hazard. Class I: there is a reasonable probability the product will cause serious adverse health consequences or death. Class II: it may cause temporary or medically reversible harm, or the chance of serious harm is remote. Class III: it is not likely to cause adverse health consequences. A committee of FDA scientists assigns the class, usually after the recalling company sends the facts. Most recalls are started by the company. The company notifies its recall coordinator, contacts every direct account, runs effectiveness checks and sends status reports until FDA terminates the recall, following 21 CFR Part 7.
What a recall class is not
- It is not a measure of how many units are affected. The class reflects health hazard only.
- It is not always FDA-ordered. Recalls can be started by the company, requested by FDA or, for some products, ordered by FDA.
- It is not the label for every product removal. A minor violation FDA would not take legal action on is a market withdrawal, not a recall.
Updated November 2026. FDA’s public recall list is a steady stream of undeclared allergens, possible Listeria contamination and supplements found to contain undeclared drug ingredients. For a brand selling online, a recall touches the label, the listing, the warehouse and every customer who bought the lot. This guide explains how FDA’s recall classes work, who decides them, what a recalling company has to do and how to prepare before anything goes wrong. It is general information, not legal advice.
Table of Contents
- What are the three FDA recall classes?
- Who decides the recall class?
- Recall, market withdrawal or safety alert: what is the difference?
- Are FDA recalls voluntary or mandatory?
- What does a brand have to do in a recall?
- Are there extra reporting duties by product type?
- How can a brand prepare before a recall?
- Where does FDA publish recalls?
- How Eva Commerce helps
- Frequently asked questions
What are the three FDA recall classes?
| Class | FDA definition (21 CFR Part 7) | Typical depth |
|---|---|---|
| Class I | Reasonable probability that use of or exposure to the product will cause serious adverse health consequences or death | Often to the consumer or user level |
| Class II | Use or exposure may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences, or the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote | Set case by case |
| Class III | Use or exposure is not likely to cause adverse health consequences | Set case by case |
FDA’s drug recall page describes Class I recalls as the most serious, urgent and generally conducted at the consumer level. The recall strategy sets the depth for each case: consumer or user level, retail level or wholesale level, depending on the hazard and how far the product was distributed.
Who decides the recall class?
Under 21 CFR 7.41, an ad hoc committee of FDA scientists runs a health hazard evaluation. It looks at whether any illness or injury has already happened, which conditions could expose people or animals to the hazard, which groups are at risk (such as children, surgical patients or pets), how serious the hazard is, how likely it is and what the immediate or long-range consequences would be. FDA then assigns Class I, II or III.
Classification usually comes after the company provides all the information FDA needs. Since June 15, 2017, FDA’s weekly Enforcement Report has also listed recalls as “not yet classified” while the hazard assessment is still underway, then updates the entry once the class is set.
Recall, market withdrawal or safety alert: what is the difference?
- Recall: a firm removes or corrects a marketed product that FDA considers in violation of the laws it administers and against which it would take legal action, such as seizure. A correction, like a relabel, counts.
- Market withdrawal: removal or correction of a product with a minor violation that would not be subject to FDA legal action. FDA’s example is a product pulled because of tampering, with no evidence of manufacturing or distribution problems.
- Medical device safety alert: issued when a device may present an unreasonable risk of substantial harm. Some are also recalls.
If you pull a product and are not sure which bucket it is in, for example because complaints or adverse reactions show something is wrong but not what, FDA asks firms to consult its office so it can help pin down the problem.
Are FDA recalls voluntary or mandatory?
FDA says recalls happen in three ways: on the firm’s own initiative, by FDA request or by FDA order under statutory authority. FDA can request a recall when a distributed product presents a risk of illness or injury or gross consumer deception, the firm has not recalled it and agency action is needed to protect public health. Mandatory authority depends on the product:
- Food, including dietary supplements: section 423 of the FD&C Act, added by the Food Safety Modernization Act.
- Medical devices: mandatory device recalls under 21 CFR Part 810, though most device recalls are voluntary under Part 7.
- Cosmetics: under MoCRA, if there is a reasonable probability a cosmetic is adulterated or misbranded and will cause serious adverse health consequences or death, FDA can order a recall when the responsible person refuses to recall voluntarily.
What does a brand have to do in a recall?
Do not wait for FDA to review your plan before you start removing product. Part 7 says the firm need not delay. The usual sequence is:
- Notify FDA immediately. Contact the recall coordinator for your product type and location. Firms outside the U.S. can reach FDA’s headquarters recall branch at OIIRecalls@fda.hhs.gov, and foreign drug and device firms report to the coordinator in the state where their U.S. Agent is located.
- Send FDA the facts listed in 21 CFR 7.46: product identity, the reason and when you found the problem, your risk evaluation, how much was made and over what period, how much is still in distribution, distribution details including direct accounts, your recall communication, your proposed strategy and a contact person.
- Set the recall strategy: depth (consumer, retail or wholesale), whether a public warning is needed and the effectiveness check level, from Level A (100% of consignees contacted) through B, C (10%), D (2%) and E (none).
- Notify every direct account. The recall communication should be brief, identify the product, size, lot numbers and codes, explain the reason and hazard, say exactly what to do with the product and give an easy way to respond. FDA asks that Class I and II recall letters and envelopes be marked “urgent.” Leave out promotional content.
- Send status reports, generally every 2 to 4 weeks, with counts of consignees notified and responding, product returned or corrected and effectiveness check results.
- Request termination in writing once the recall is effective, with your latest status report and how the product was disposed of. FDA terminates a recall when all reasonable efforts have been made.
Are there extra reporting duties by product type?
- Food: registered food facilities must report through the Reportable Food Registry when there is a reasonable probability a food will cause serious adverse health consequences or death. The Registry does not cover dietary supplements or infant formula.
- Medical devices: under 21 CFR Part 806, manufacturers and importers must report a correction or removal made to reduce a risk to health, within 10 working days of starting it. Actions that would be Class III recalls only need records, not a report.
How can a brand prepare before a recall?
FDA’s general industry guidance in 21 CFR 7.59 comes down to three things: keep a current written recall plan, code products well enough to identify every lot and keep distribution records for longer than the product’s shelf life and expected use. For brands selling online, that means:
- lot or batch codes on every unit, matched to the contract manufacturer’s batch records (supplement brands should see our 21 CFR 111 CGMP guide);
- knowing which warehouses, fulfillment centers and 3PLs hold which lots, and which customer orders shipped from each lot;
- a plan to pause listings on every marketplace and your own store within hours, and to follow each marketplace’s own recall process;
- a label review habit, since undeclared allergens are a frequent recall reason. Our food labeling and allergen guide covers the rules, and food brands should also read our FSMA 204 traceability guide.
Where does FDA publish recalls?
Every recall FDA monitors goes into the weekly Enforcement Report as Class I, II, III or not yet classified. Company press releases appear on FDA’s Recalls, Market Withdrawals and Safety Alerts page, which keeps them for three years before archiving. Not every recall gets a press release. A recall can follow a Form 483 or a warning letter, so treat those as early signals.
How Eva Commerce helps
Eva Commerce does not run recalls and is not a law firm, so bring in counsel for recall decisions. We help prevent the label problems that lead to many recalls: basic label formatting review is $340 per label and full compliance review, covering claims and allergens, is $590 per label. We also keep FDA registrations and U.S. Agent service ($250 a year) current, so FDA can reach you fast. Prices are on our FDA compliance services page.
Because Eva also runs Amazon, Walmart, TikTok Shop and Shopify growth, we can help pause and fix listings across channels when a lot has a problem. Book a call or call 858-315-2020 to review your labels and recall readiness.
Frequently asked questions
What is a Class 1 recall?
A Class I recall is FDA’s most serious class: there is a reasonable probability that using or being exposed to the product will cause serious adverse health consequences or death.
What is the difference between a Class 2 and Class 3 recall?
A Class II product may cause temporary or medically reversible harm, or serious harm is remote. A Class III product is not likely to cause adverse health consequences but still violates FDA law.
Who classifies an FDA recall?
An ad hoc committee of FDA scientists runs a health hazard evaluation under 21 CFR 7.41 and assigns Class I, II or III. Until then, the Enforcement Report can show “not yet classified.”
Are FDA recalls mandatory?
Most are started by the company. FDA can request a recall, and it can order one for food under FD&C Act section 423, for devices under 21 CFR Part 810 and for cosmetics under MoCRA.
How often must a recalling firm report to FDA?
FDA sets the interval for each recall, generally every 2 to 4 weeks. Status reports stop once FDA terminates the recall.
Can Eva Commerce help me avoid a labeling recall?
Yes. Eva reviews labels for allergens, claims and required elements for $340 (basic) or $590 (full compliance) per label. Book a call or call 858-315-2020.
Sources: FDA, Recalls Background and Definitions; 21 CFR Part 7, Enforcement Policy; FDA, Initiation of Voluntary Recalls Under 21 CFR Part 7, Subpart C; FDA, Enforcement Reports; FDA, Recall Coordinators; FDA, Questions and Answers Regarding Mandatory Food Recalls; FDA, Questions and Answers Regarding Mandatory Cosmetics Recalls; FDA, Recalls, Corrections and Removals (Devices); FDA, Reportable Food Registry for Industry; FDA, Understanding Drug Recalls; FDA, Recalls, Market Withdrawals and Safety Alerts. General information, not legal advice.