Download "Amazon Advertising Playbook Strategies to Drive Profitable Growth". Get The PDF

Can You Sell the Same Product with Amazon FBA and FBM?

Can I Do Both FBA and FBM

Quick answer: Yes. A seller can offer the same ASIN through FBA and FBM by using separate seller SKUs tied to the existing product detail page. Do not create a duplicate ASIN. Keep inventory, shipping promises, pricing, and order routing accurate for each fulfillment method.

Quick answer

Yes. A seller can offer the same ASIN through FBA and FBM by using separate seller SKUs tied to the existing product detail page. Do not create a duplicate ASIN. Keep inventory, shipping promises, pricing, and order routing accurate for each fulfillment method.

Both Amazon FBA and FBM come with numerous pros and cons. In this blog post, we’re going to tell you how to take a smart strategy to list your items with both fulfillment methods to literally have the best of both worlds! Let’s go!

What Are Amazon FBM and FBA?

Quick answer: Amazon FBA is one of the most innovative eCommerce solutions. It simplifies sellers to sell faster without overthinking shipment and fulfillment. Amazon has one of the most advanced fulfillment networks in the world. With Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), you store your products in Amazon’s fulfillment centers, and Amazon takes care of picking, packing, shipping, and providing customer service for these products.

Amazon FBA is one of the most innovative eCommerce solutions. It simplifies sellers to sell faster without overthinking shipment and fulfillment. Amazon has one of the most advanced fulfillment networks in the world. With Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), you store your products in Amazon’s fulfillment centers, and Amazon takes care of picking, packing, shipping, and providing customer service for these products. As a result, FBA can help sellers scale their business and reach more customers.

For the customers, the benefits are enormous too. If the customer is prime, within 1-2 days, the customer can receive the item without paying the additional cost and enjoy Amazon customer service. However, 97% of prime customers do not look at who is selling the items. They trust Amazon’s capability to check the quality, package, and delivery in the expected time frame. The seller can start benefiting from this trust from day one.

See Also: Amazon FBA vs FBM

Can I Do Both FBA and FBM?

Quick answer: Yes, you can. Amazon lets you list the same item for both FBA and FBM. Currently, selling FBA is the primary way for Amazon private Label sellers and Resellers. It is a great practice, but for the same item, there are ways where FBM can help.

Yes, you can. Amazon lets you list the same item for both FBA and FBM. Currently, selling FBA is the primary way for Amazon private Label sellers and Resellers. It is a great practice, but for the same item, there are ways where FBM can help.

FBM stands for “Fulfilled By Merchant,” meaning that the seller ships the orders, similar to selling on your website. The seller sets the shipping rates and processing times, and the seller is responsible for getting the order to the customer in the time you’ve specified.

Eva is the only software service where you can manage both FBA and FBM simultaneously. Most of the new sellers are not aware of that, and there are several advantages of doing that.

Benefits of Listing on Amazon FBM and FBA

Stock-out Problems

Quick answer: Stock-outs are a nightmare for private label sellers. Eva uses sales velocity, category analysis, and seasonal trends to avoid Stock-outs or delay the stock-out. Eva checks various factors for the best time to replenish the items and immediately alerts the Private label seller on re-stocking time.

Stock-outs are a nightmare for private label sellers. Eva uses sales velocity, category analysis, and seasonal trends to avoid Stock-outs or delay the stock-out. Eva checks various factors for the best time to replenish the items and immediately alerts the Private label seller on re-stocking time. But sometimes, there are challenges with logistics or manufacturing where the seller cannot re-stock the items. Like, such as a customs issue or an ingredient to manufacture the product is missing.

In all these cases, having an FBM listing is a great help. We can not assume the same sales velocity with FBM as the FBA, but it helps the Keyword rankings and BSR Rankings stay stable or minimizes the impact. Customers still have the option to buy the item, which affects customer satisfaction.

Reaching Out to Non-Prime Consumers

Quick answer: Do you know that Amazon is projecting to have more than 150 Million households have prime membership by 2022? Amazon Prime is a fantastic service with many advantages, but some other customers are not prime.

Do you know that Amazon is projecting to have more than 150 Million households have prime membership by 2022? Amazon Prime is a fantastic service with many advantages, but some other customers are not prime. Also, prime consumer numbers are much less in other Amazon marketplaces like Mexico or Canada.

When non-prime customers want to buy Amazon FBA, Amazon may charge them shipment fees. So at least they can also have an option to purchase via FBM, which can perhaps be a little bit cheaper. Giving both options to the customer can accelerate the decision. The essential decision factor for FBA will be the speed of the delivery, wherewith FBM; the seller may decide to pay less.

In any case, for FBM customers, the seller has complete visibility of the buyer’s personal information, which is a unique value that’s not available via Amazon FBA.

Know Your Customer

Quick answer: If you are a Private Label, you may want to know your customers and build customer-focused strategies. Even if you are an FBM seller, you might find this approach relevant. We recommend you use FBA as the main fulfillment strategy but getting information about your customers is valuable.

If you are a Private Label, you may want to know your customers and build customer-focused strategies. Even if you are an FBM seller, you might find this approach relevant. We recommend you use FBA as the main fulfillment strategy but getting information about your customers is valuable. It may help you do surveys, understand customer intent, and offer these customers new products. So it would not hurt to have a small set of customers that you know and who are using your product.

Read More: Amazon Plan of Action (POA)

Amazon seller fees for FBA and FBM

Amazon seller fees are the combined costs of a selling plan, referral fees, fulfillment, storage, removals, and related chargebacks. Fee economics should sit next to the FBA vs FBM decision, because fulfillment choice changes which fee lines matter most.

What Amazon seller fees include

Most sellers should evaluate five cost groups: selling-plan fees, referral fees, fulfillment fees, storage fees, and exception costs. Exception costs include returns processing, removals, disposal, unplanned service charges, and charges caused by inaccurate catalog or inventory data. The exact amount varies by product and program, so use Amazon’s current fee schedules as the source of record before making a pricing decision.

Selling-plan and referral fees

Amazon offers different selling-plan structures. The choice should reflect transaction volume, operating needs, and the tools required to run the catalog. Plan selection is only the starting point. Referral fees are typically the more important recurring variable because they are tied to the sale and can differ by category. A finance model should use the applicable category rate, not a sitewide average.

That distinction matters when a brand sells across categories or changes bundle composition. A product can look profitable at a blended fee assumption and unprofitable once its actual category, promotion, return rate, and fulfillment profile are applied. For pricing context, see Eva’s Amazon pricing strategy guide.

FBA fees versus FBM costs

Fulfillment by Amazon can simplify delivery and customer-service operations, but it does not make fulfillment free. FBA costs generally depend on the item’s size and weight tier and may also be affected by special handling requirements. Fulfilled by Merchant shifts fulfillment work to the seller, which can reduce some marketplace charges but adds warehouse, labor, shipping, service, and returns responsibilities.

The right decision is not “FBA is cheaper” or “FBM is cheaper.” It is which route creates the best contribution margin and customer experience for a specific SKU. Include inbound freight, prep, packaging, storage, return rate, delivery promise, and operational capacity in the comparison. Inventory decisions are equally important; Eva’s Amazon inventory management guide explains why stock planning affects both cost and availability.

Storage, aged inventory, and removal costs

Storage is where a product’s economics can change after launch. Slow-moving inventory consumes space, ties up working capital, and can create additional charges as inventory ages. The operational answer is rarely to cut price automatically. First confirm demand, listing quality, advertising efficiency, replenishment timing, and whether the assortment still fits the channel.

Brands should review aged inventory at the SKU level, decide whether to sell through, remove, liquidate, or reposition it, and document the reason for each action. When fulfillment discrepancies create recoverable charges, the workflow is different from normal fee management; see Eva’s Amazon FBA reimbursement guide.

How to calculate Amazon selling costs by SKU

A calculator can speed up the arithmetic, but it cannot replace clean source data. Update the model when product dimensions, category assignments, fulfillment tiers, supplier costs, or fee schedules change. The most useful model is connected to catalog and inventory decisions rather than maintained as a one-time spreadsheet.

More short, sourced answers: Eva Answers.

  • Start with the selling price excluding tax treatment that does not belong in revenue.
  • Subtract the category-specific referral fee.
  • Subtract the applicable fulfillment route cost, including FBA or merchant-fulfilled operations.
  • Include inbound freight, prep, packaging, storage, expected returns, and promotion costs.

Amazon seller fees at a glance

Amazon seller fees usually stack three layers: a monthly Professional selling plan (or per-item fee on Individual), referral fees by category, and FBA fulfillment plus storage when you use Fulfillment by Amazon. Exact rates change by category and size tier, so treat the tables on this page as the working reference.

Related: Amazon account management · How much does it cost to sell on Amazon?

Referral fee types and costs by category

The original category table is retained because referral fees are not uniform. Use it as a planning reference only, then verify every applicable percentage and minimum fee against Amazon’s current Seller Central schedule before publishing or changing a price. Categories, thresholds, and fee rules can change.

How fee changes affect pricing decisions

A price increase does not always improve margin by the same amount. Referral fees, promotions, tax treatment, fulfillment tiers, return rates, and advertising spend can all alter the incremental contribution from an extra dollar of revenue. Teams should therefore model a normal price, a promotional price, and a recovery price before approving discounts.

Start with the SKU’s actual selling price and subtract the applicable referral fee. Add the fulfillment route, packaging, inbound freight, storage exposure, return allowance, and expected advertising cost. The remaining amount is the contribution available to cover product cost and overhead. If the figure is thin, the action may be to improve conversion, reduce a cost driver, or change the assortment, not simply spend more on ads.

Inventory creates costs even before a sale

Inventory planning belongs in a seller-fee review because storage cost and capital exposure begin before the customer orders. Excess inventory can create storage and removal decisions, while too little inventory can interrupt sales velocity and make advertising less efficient. The best replenishment plan balances availability, lead time, margin, and expected demand.

Review slow-moving SKUs separately from fast-moving winners. A slow SKU may need a listing correction, price test, promotion, bundle strategy, removal, or a decision to stop replenishing. A fast SKU may justify more inventory only if its contribution margin remains healthy after all marketplace costs are included.

A monthly operating review for seller fees

At minimum, review the top revenue SKUs, the lowest-margin SKUs, products with rising storage exposure, and products with unusual returns. Compare planned costs with settlement data and document material differences. Then assign an owner: catalog for attributes, supply chain for packaging and replenishment, finance for margin assumptions, and advertising for spend targets.

For larger catalogs, the review should be continuous rather than a quarterly clean-up. Product-level profitability becomes more useful when fee data, inventory signals, and advertising outcomes are examined together. That is the difference between merely reporting costs and managing them.

This fee guide was merged from Eva’s Amazon seller fees page so FBA/FBM and fee planning live together. For managed operations, see Amazon account management or book a call.

Updated November 2026

Conclusion

Eva is the only repricer software for Private Labels and Resellers that can price both FBA and FBM options of the same SKU.

Eva calculates the initial pricing based on the product and shipment costs and your Minimum ROI. After that, Eva ensures that FBA SKU gets the Buy Box while FBM SKU is priced based on the competition and FBA SKU follows the FBA SKU.

If you have more questions about this smart trick, feel free to get a Free Consultation from Eva now!

About the author: Hai Mag is the founder of Eva Commerce and writes about Amazon, Walmart, TikTok Shop, advertising, and marketplace profitability from hands-on operator experience.

Hai Mag Ceo

Hai Mag

Hai Mag, Founder & CEO of Eva Commerce, is a visionary leader in eCommerce and AI-driven automation with 20+ years of experience in business transformation, marketplace optimization, and growth hacking.
Amazon logo

Amazon Growth System

Full-service Amazon management across PPC, DSP, SEO (Alexa), content, inventory, and operations

Amazon Ads Advanced Partner badge
Amazon Marketplace Developer Council badge
Shopify Partner badge
TikTok Shop Marketing Partner badge
Google Premier Partner badge
Meta Business Partner badge
Walmart Advertising Partner badge
Partner Badges 09

Keep up with the latest from Eva